I’ll make my position clear at the beginning, we must not let this guy go, he cannot be cut adrift due to media hysteria even if we get handed our arses in a 5-0 trouncing. However, he has made mistakes, mistakes that he will not acknowledge and this is something that must change. Anyone closely involved in elite sport must have self confidence verging on the infallible, but equally has got to understand the space between ‘infallible’ and ‘verging on’. He’s not omniscient, and even if he was it does not preclude the possibility of applying this knowledge incorrectly. Stop trying to snow the media and the general public because it is damaging your standing. The media’s memory maybe very short but I hope the general public’s is a little longer and we still remember the success the team brought to the country in 2005 and just because he was self effacing in victory then does not exculpate him in defeat now.
Fess up and commit to undertaking a critical review of your and your teams performance, publicly invite and agree to consider criticism, review your approach to loyalty, clearly this trait has it’s place but it needs to be tempered with form considerations. The captaincy needs to be looked at, is Flintoff’s output being compromised by the captaincy? He needs to play hard for Lancashire at the beginning of the ’07 season and see where his form really is and then see how it translates to the test arena, but this highlights another aspect of Fletcher’s stewardship, the amount of county cricket he allows the central contract players to play. This may be redundant if Vaughan returns but that remains imponderable at this point in time, form and capability remain unproven.
With everyone fit we still have a squad to compete with the best in the world, which remains Australia don’t forget, and I have no problem with this squad including Geraint Jones and Ashley Giles. He should remain loyal to this squad as a whole, not just to eleven of them.
Fletcher’s position won’t be reviewed by his bosses until after the World Cup but realistically they might as well take a view now. We are not going to set the world alight in the West Indies and unless Fletcher is so intransigent that the England and Wales Cricket Board feel the need for a stick to beat him with to have him change his ways then the go or stay decision should be made at the end of the Australia tour.
Fletcher remains the best man for the job but with subtle changes in emphasis he could be even more successful.